sh4w's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Salad Fingers 10]

Genuinely outstanding. I've been watching these half my life and this is definitely the best in almost every respect. You're a talented man!

[Red Diamond Dragon Club]

My favourite flash of all time, full stop.

I've seen thousands of flashes, and this is literally the funniest, most imaginitive one I've seen. I love it. You did duch a great job, please make more :)

[Socklops]

Fantastic

This was ac tually my favourite of all your cartoons, and I've seen all of them. It was hypnotic. I was thoroughly entertained throughout by your unique style. Can't wait for the next, you're basically the only author I look on NG for to see if there's another submission.

[Weird Al - You're Pitiful]

Overall, average.

The song was masterful, like all Weird Al songs. But of course, you didn't create it. The graphics were ok, as was the video itself. THe lip-synching was a big letdown, if you fixed that you'd have a significantly better flash.

[Submit]

Interesting

I like it, it's original and I liked the artistic style of the movie, it was a nice interpretation of an .swf going through judgement. Well done :)

[American Idle]

Brilliant

A very impressive flash, great graphics, creative and funny. I thought the voices were very good too, you really captured some of the gestures from Numa Numa very realistically, you should be proud of this creation.

[New Numa]

A Letdown

Well, it seems the fame has gone to your head. It's time to accept that the original Numa Numa was brilliant, but it was a one-off. A wonderful concept of an ordinary fat guy miming a foreign song in an amateurish video. This was much worse, the song was boring, it wasn't funny. Your idea has no further to go, adding extra people, better video quality and different scenes will never improve upon your original. You are a one hit wonder and you've had your fame, stop flogging a dead horse and find something else to do. Your "talents" don' belong in a professional-looking music video. I don't like the self-promotion and the fact that you seem to think you're a celebrity. Please don't make another one, lest you desecrate the memory of wonderful first video even further. If you can't improve on your original creation (and you can't) then don't try.
-Sh4w

[South park Indian Jones]

Abysmal

That was one of the worst submissions I have ever seen pass judgement. An Unoriginal, badly animated, plotless "movie" with an irritating soundtrack. South Park is a great Show, why would you portray it's characters in such an unprecented piece of crap like that? If you're that poor at flash, start at the beginning, draw your own characters. I'll never know why anyone voted higher than a "0" on this, please don't submit anything to NG again unless you're sure its 10 times better than that.

[the YuYu]

Disappointing

I have to say, I felt this was far inferior to your other movies. Whilst your graphics were, as usual, stunning and I can't even begin to conceive how you would animate like that, there was no story and 30 seconds in I was bored. I didn't think much of the music either. Art and animation alone does not make a movie, and I think you should concentrate on making your short stories, which are brilliant.
Good luck.

[The Ultimate Showdown]

Brilliant

I loved it! The song was excellent and you did a great job with the animation. The only thing that could be improved in my opinion is small parts of the animation are a bit lacking, such as Jackie Chan doing a somersault, but who am I to complain, I couldn't make that. Keep up the great work :)